So here is a very interesting data point, from one recent Pointroll campaign that had part of the ad impressions benefiting from Yahoo! BT data and the other part of the impressions did not include any BT data.
BT enabled Pointroll ads had a 41% overall higher interaction rate than non-BT enabled Pointroll ads.
Same creative. Same publisher. Same timeframe. Basically as many other variables were held constant between the two groups except the inclusion of BT data within the test group. Sure, its not airtight statistically sound case due to the single campaign data point, but its very indicative of other similar campaign results the team has seen when comparing BT enabled ad results with those that did not receive any additional insights from BT data.
The important point to take away is BT works. By using user level “hints” to better select what creative, copy and content elements should be inserted into the ad units, BT enabled ads are just more relevant and personalized to the user. Therefore its no surprise that these more personalized ads receive more interest as expressed in either interactions or clicks.
If we look at click-thru rates as another meaningful measure, BT enabled Pointroll ads had a 73.5% overall higher click-thru rate than non-BT enabled Pointroll ads.
Pointroll’s AdControl is a very powerful tool. So much so, that it becomes somewhat difficult to explain and talk about to others at times. However within the below interactive demo, this complexity issue is solved. Basically it allows business rules to be created that give advertisers more control of the content within their rich media ad unit.
A rule might be when a user fitting the profile of “Type 1″ comes in contact with a PaperBoy ad that is about to render, always make sure to show a background image of a tool shed, use a call to action that includes the copy “Roll over” and to display a bag of all purpose fertilizer. Or if you are a visual person, display this exact combination within the ad unit as follows:
Input: User Type1. Output: Tool shed background image + "Roll Over" call to action copy + "Vigoro Fertilizer" product
Pretty darn cool. The combinations are endless. However the real fun begins when one starts to bring in publisher supplied BT data such as gender, age and interest(s) of the user. Then these types of rules become very powerful once you layer in the auto optimization factors that the system (e.g., AdControl) offer so that the most successful (which can be custom configured) ad combinations receive the highest amount of impressions.
This is a very visual way of showing how different pieces of PaperBoy ad content such as the call to action copy, products or the background image can be tied to specific user types (or BT segments in some cases)
The demographic and behavioral targeting (BT) enhanced PaperBoy ads that run under the Yahoo! white labeled product name of “Smart Ads” are finally certified. This means that there has been a detailed inspection of all the ad metrics, ad performance, ad serving, etc by the Yahoo! Smart Ads team and that Pointroll passed with flying colors. Nice work everyone at Pointroll and ShopLocal in passing this important external validation step.
Here is one interesting tidbit that helps validate why there is a need for dynamic generated and machine optimized rich media ads.
So if there are 300 weekly ad items live at any given point in time, and you needed to pick four specific products to include in a ad, there would be 300 + 299 + 298 + 297 possibilities (which is 1,195 options as each of the four outputs are calculated independently). This is why it is only possible to do this type of optimization via machine optimization and learning.
Here is a nice flashy demo that Yahoo! put together that overviews the SmartAds program
Hooray! ShopLocal and Pointroll are now official partners
The press pickup has been amazing with over 200+ sites running the story, so thank you to all. Here are some soundbites from a few more notable sources:
- ADOTAS: “As a member of Yahoo’s Smart Ads program, PointRoll will leverage Yahoo’s reach and targeting capabilities to provide even more customized, relevant, and scalable rich media campaigns. PointRoll will also leverage its ShopLocal retail advertising program in order to offer enhanced Smart Ads for retail advertisers.”
- ClickZ: “Rich media firm PointRoll will tap Yahoo’s ad-targeting technology to deliver those ads to the right audiences, according to PointRoll CEO Jason Tafler. PointRoll’s ShopLocal retail ads will also be part of the Smart Ads program.” – ClickZ
- WebProNews: “Smart Ads can be used in any vertical industry, but Yahoo says it has seen success within the retail industry, where many advertisers are looking for new ways to reach consumers. Testing Smart Ads with ShopLocal retail ad content has shown improved campaign performance for retail advertisers such as CVS and Kohl’s. These advertisers saw gains in click performance, conversion and overall return on investment.” -
And finally, here is a link to the official release and some generic info on the Yahoo! Smart Ad program overall.
This is a really big deal. To fully onboard and integrate around the (below) top portal publishers and ad networks that have demographic AND behavioral (collectively referred to as “BT data herein) data on their users in a way so that Pointroll PaperBoy ads can use these user-level BT insights to actually change WHAT content is actually shown within the ad units. This is cutting edge, one-to-one data driven marketing. Every single ad that gets served has the potential to be different and uniquely tailored (from a content perspective) for every unique user.
- Platform-a: There are two (2) parts that make collectively makeup Platform-a which are…
- Advertising.com (the 3rd party ad network)
- AOL (owned and operated sites that are BT powered by Tacoda)
- quadrantONE
- CollectiveMedia
- Yahoo!
These are the current publisher / ad network partners that ShopLocal and Pointroll have integrated the publisher provided BT data into the PaperBoy product. More publishers are in the works that will be launching soon.
At an unique user level (so for any given ad impression), these premier publishers and ad networks typically can provide the below insights:
- ZIP Code (and sometimes other higher level GeoLocation data is available)
- Gender
- Race
- Age / Year Of Birth (sometimes age ranges and sometimes exact birth year)
- Categor(ies) Of Interest (that the user has shown a past interest in – can be multiple)
- Publisher Property Type (helps determine the context of publisher page were the ad will be inserted – ex. finance.yahoo.com
- Publisher Page Position (helps determine the actual placement of the ad – ex. MPU above the fold)
- Publisher Page Context Keyword(s)
A couple of important notes however around these publishers provided BT targeting data:
- The amount (eg depth) of BT insights for any given ad impressions varies per publisher from some impressions having:
- No BT data available
- Only some BT data available
- Very complete sets of BT data available
- Which BT data points are collected and maintained varies from publisher to publisher. Not everyone for example has age data on it’s users
- The BT data collection methodology greatly varies from publisher to publisher. How extensive and wide any given publishers reaches into web logs, search histories, registration data, etc is all part of the secret special sauce that each publisher maintains
- The frequency of how often the BT data is updated is also a variable across publishers
- Storage, re-use and re-distribution of this publisher owned and controlled BT data is clearly prohibited and ShopLocal and Pointroll tightly adhere to this policy as it helps protects our publisher partner’s interests
- Privacy is one of the biggest concerns throughout the entire process. With all the recent self-imposed industry regulations around BT targeted online advertising, all parties have been very careful to be very respectful of the end users’ privacy throughout all of the design and integrations steps. Our goal is to actual try to offer user a more personalized, more relevant overall site experience which includes the content within the display ads
- From a publisher perspective: All information about any given user is 100% anonymous with no personally identifiable information (PII) being passed over to ShopLocal or Pointroll
- From an ad server (Pointroll) perspective: All ads do not directly capture any PII which includes, but isn’t limited to, e-mail addresses, telephone numbers, and credit card numbers. No sensitive information is collected via the the ads. We even extend this by not allowing the cookies dropped to users machines to associate with any personally-identifiable information. (For purposes of this post, personally-identifiable information doesn’t include IP addresses or ZIP code)
- From a localized content provider (ShopLocal) perspective: No PII is collected or stored or the user
Some of the next steps that the ShopLocal and Pointroll teams are gearing up to undertake:
So “selling futures” is a common PR trick in the technology world. I’m not a huge fan, but I am a fan of showing real customers and partners glimpses of what is about to happen so that real market feedback and guidance can help shape the product.
Reading crystal balls and tea leaves is difficult, but one such soon-to-come strategic enhancement for PaperBoy will be the addition (or really deep integration) of Pointroll’s new AdControl system. The goal is to allow this dynamic ad generation tool to control (update & optimize) on a micro-targeted basis the following types of ad variables:
- Web site / publisher
- Ad placement
- Geography
- Publisher generated behavioral, demographic, or contextual data
AdControl also measures all the typical rich media metrics including:
- Interaction rate
- Brand time
- Click through
But aggregates the results of these and other metrics by individual creative and delivery variables. This capability enables more robust testing and optimization, as the technology will identify each ad version created and evaluate its performance as a single unit and against other versions, or as part of an entire campaign.
AdControl allows retailers and their agencies can produce, target and deliver PaperBoy ads dynamically, customizing creative elements including video, content, images, offers and more – all in real time and by non-technical personnel via an online interface
Where this powerful combination of the in-store, on sale offer data that ShopLocal offers + robust localized rich media functionality that PaperBoy offers + the dynamic creative and targeting controls that AdControl offers is…
- Creative Control: Imagine an ad unit where the background image is dynamically changed in run time based upon the user’s location. So if this was for a retailer like Walgreen’s, this would allow a user in Florida to have a sunny beach background while for the same retailer a user in Minnesota may have a snow lake background. This is an over-simplified example for sure, but it make the point. Any creative element (button, copy, images, text, etc) can now all be driven by extensive, easy-to-create and mange business rules
- Content Control: Image an ad unit where the offers (eg the products) that are displayed change based upon multiple factors such as the age of a user, the context of the placement and the categorical interest(s) of the user. So the women that is age 25 and has a strong category affinity to “fashion” gets women’s junior apparel content served into the PaperBoy ad unit vs. the man age 50 that likes “sports” would get golf clubs content inserted into his PaperBoy ad unit
Here are a few background resources to aide in getting a deeper understanding of AdControl:
Loading ...
(4.33 out of 5)
Comments: None